Souderton Settlement: $63,000 Fee, Livestreaming Mandate
The school district must create an outdoor demonstration zone and pay legal costs following a two-year dispute over resident bans.
By Patrick Sullivan ·

The Souderton Area School District will pay $63,000 in attorneys' fees to residents and establish a designated outdoor space for demonstrations outside its administrative offices. This settlement resolves a lawsuit filed in 2024 by the ACLU of Pennsylvania and Ramsingh Legal, PLLC, after the district banned three local residents from attending school board meetings.
The legal dispute originated in September 2024, when the district prohibited Patrick Kitt, Christopher Spigel, and Spigel’s teenage daughter from entering meetings. The group had been protesting school board member Bill Formica following his social media posts about Kamala Harris. District officials claimed the residents threatened board member Kim Wheeler and her daughter in a parking lot. District solicitor Jeffrey Sultanik wrote in an October 2024 letter that the residents yelled, “Tell your father he’s an {expletive},” and “Tell her dad he’s a fascist and needs to resign.”
The ACLU argued the district misidentified the target of the confrontation. The group stated that the residents believed Wheeler’s daughter was Formica’s daughter. The district lifted the ban in March 2025. A tentative settlement reached early that year required the district to livestream and archive meetings, create a demonstration area, pay legal fees, and issue a joint press release. The residents also agreed to provide a confidential apology to Wheeler’s daughter if these conditions were met.
Negotiations stalled in April when the school board rejected the joint press release and demanded the plaintiffs keep the settlement private. The district’s attorney subsequently sought a court order to bar the residents from discussing the case and required them to waive the right to file criminal complaints related to the 2024 incident. Kitt said he “lost all trust that the school board was operating in good faith” after the district attempted to use the apology against the group.
Judge Mia Roberts Perez reviewed the binding nature of the settlement in September. She ruled that while the district failed to prove the agreement was fully approved by the board, the parties should still follow it. However, she struck the clause requiring a compulsory apology, stating that the First Amendment limits the court's ability to force such an action. She noted it is ethical to apologize when an adult harms a child, even inadvertently, but cannot compel it through litigation. The district did not appeal the order.
Under the final terms, the district must continue livestreaming and archiving its board meetings, a practice it began in early 2025. The new requirements also mandate a designated outdoor gathering area adjacent to the district’s administrative building. Sara Rose, the ACLU’s deputy legal director, stated that members of the public have a First Amendment right to participate in these public proceedings.
District Superintendent Christopher Hey did not respond to requests for comment on the final agreement. The settlement concludes the litigation but leaves the district with ongoing obligations to maintain the new transparency and spatial measures for future meetings.
More Business · Consumer Watch · Report a business · Got a Story?






